Saturday, September 29, 2012
Saturday, August 25, 2012
Learning Futures
I might start with this video from the Paul Hamlyn Foundation on Learning Futures.
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Recognising and Measuring Teaching Effectiveness
To support our learning as a team in doing our work I have established a work blog that is used to share and develop thinking and ideas related to the work of the Professional Leadership and Development Unit of the Catholic Education Office Sydney.
I posted the following for members of the team to engage with and thought that it may be worth sharing more widely.
There is currently some serious discussion and thinking being put into the connection between teachers' pay, the quality of teaching and student performance. (See Sydney Morning Herald 17/03/2011)
Much has been made of the 2007 McKinsey Report, How the world's best performing school systems come out on top, as has been made of Hattie's 2008 work, Visible Learning particularly concerning teachers and what they do.
This research has often been reduced to a simplistic mantra: "It is what teachers do that matters for students and their learning."
One of the areas that is on our agenda is building the capacity of teachers: those graduate teachers who are commencing their careers, but also experienced teachers who wish to engage with the higher level professional standards for teaching.
Linked with this are a number of issues:
- What works in developing the early career teacher? (Types of induction? Use of mentors? Reflective practice?)
- Capacity of supervisor in recognising teaching standards in practice? (Use of standards? Understanding standards? Own practice? Who should be a supervisor?)
- Locating accreditation processes into a career long learning framework rather than a compliance exercise.
- Developing higher level skill in teachers to benefit the profession.
If we are to lead the thinking about building the capacity of teachers we need to address the question of building capacity from what towards what; and in what context and for what purpose.
Simon Breakspear earlier this year posted the following on his blog:
There is some increasingly interesting research coming out of the States which is seeking to investigate the ‘black box’ of successful schools – what do effective teachers do?
Harvard’s Tom Kane backed by Gates Foundation funding is conducting one of the most remarkable projects yet. Launched in the fall of 2009, the Measures of Effective Teaching Project is the largest effort of its kind to collect video, student perceptions, and assessments of student achievement and teacher knowledge. The project’s goal is to learn what effective teaching looks like.The website for Measures of Effective Teaching is worth having a look at.
Your thoughts and experiences would be welcomed.
Image: http://www.flickr.com/photos/51023923@N07/4688182943/sizes/m/in/photostream/
Thursday, January 13, 2011
Trying to meet the future by doing what we did in the past
This is because it's in the gene pool of education.
Public education is a product of The Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution. The Enlightenment constructed a view of the mind, and as such the learner and also the curriculum. The Industrial Revolution provided an economic reason for public education. Our present model of schooling is modelled on the interest and the image of industrialism.
Robinson argues that models of learning (and therefore schooling) need to go in the opposite direction to standardisation; standardisation reflected in curriculum and testing. This doesn't imply a lowering of standards.
Below is the RSA animation to the talk (11mins 40 sec).
- What are our new models of learning?
- How can education best meet the future?
- What leadership is needed?
- How can this change be brought about?
- What is needed to make this change last?
Friday, December 31, 2010
Born Creative ...
Born Creative is a new publication from DEMOS (the London-based think tank).Wednesday, December 01, 2010
Australian Educational Policy – Starting to Listen?
I wrote earlier about the Australian take on the 'accountability framework' – it seemed like publishing student/teacher results on a national website was bound to lead to league performance tables by any other means. A week later – and I'm sure my post had nothing to do with it – state Education Ministers were in Canberra, meeting to discuss 'school performance'. I happened to be in Parliament House at the time they were discussing it, and joked with colleagues that, if they'd let me in, I'd tell them to avoid league tables at all costs. Lo and behold, they seem to have reached that conclusion anyway, according to this article in the Sydney Morning Herald. The problem was familiar, the solution, unfamiliar – prevent the aggregation of individual school reporting into a national blunt instrument. Minister Gove, please take note.
And then there's the development of the National Curriculum. With the best of intentions, the Federal government had aspired to create a Finnish 'pared-down' curriculum, which would encourage flexibility. The consultation process, however, has spawned too much elaboration leading to criticisms of the draft curriculum as 'overcrowded and incoherent' . Amazingly enough, the government seems to be listening, and the intention is now to scale back in future drafts.
So, from a UK viewpoint, a familiar set of issues. But an unfamiliar response, in that people seem to be listening to school principals, teachers and – as in the event I attended last week in Melbourne, courtesy of Musical Futures school, Trafalgar Primary – listening to learners themselves. We (including our popular press) could learn a lot from the way schooling is publicly discussed in Australia.
Saturday, September 25, 2010
Saturday, July 10, 2010
Conversation from Penn State with Sir Ken Robinson: Education Innovation - Learning the true meaning of creativity
I woke up this morning to find I'd received the following email from Stephanie Williams from WPSU/Penn State Public Broadcasting:As I'm sure you're aware, many experts believe the education system in the U.S. needs significant restructuring. WPSU-TV recently interviewed Sir Ken Robinson on a series called “Conversations From Penn State” where he discussed the problems facing the education system and suggests ways to improve it by promoting creativity. After reading through your blog, I think you and your readers may be interested in the interview. It can be found at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tL0WW3tR8Kc and I have provided the embed code at the bottom of this message if you wish to share the video. Please let me know if you have any question or if you decide to post the video.Sincerely,Stephanie Williams
- People underestimate themselves
- The problem is the education system, not teachers and principals
- Transformation is what's required, not reform
- There's an obsession with Standardised Testing
- Schooling is resulting in "standardising" kids
- Reforms are focused on teacher-proofing.
What sparked your interest in education?
Many Government policy makers invest huge amounts of time, money and energy in attempts to teacher-proof the system through public accountability resulting in standardisation: teacher standards, leadership standards, standardised testing, public reporting of results comparing schools, common curriculum.
Students regularly comment that it is the teachers who were significant to them at school. It's teachers (or other mentors) who can result in students realising their passion, and perhaps their full potential.
Wednesday, June 30, 2010
Maths needs a makeover
- Use multimedia
- Encourage student intuition
- Ask the shortest questions you can
- Let students build the problem
- Be less helpful.
"Maths makes sense of the world. Maths is the vocabulary of your own intuition."
"We need more patient problem-solvers!"
Friday, June 04, 2010
Imagining Possibilities
Bring on the Learning Revolution
- Education dislocates people from their natural talents.
- Reforming education systems is of little use because it's trying to improve a broken model.
- What is required is a revolution that transforms the system into something else.
- Innovation is fundamental to the required transformation.
- We need to challenge what we take for granted.
- The Tyranny of Common Sense works against transformation.
- The Narrative of Linearity in education (ie. it starts here and finishes here) is an example of what is taken fro granted.
- "A three-year old isn't half a six-year old!"
- Education results in conformity through a fast food model.
- Passion is what excites the spirit and gives energy.
- Does education feed people's passions?
- Human flourishing is organic not mechanical.
- "Tread softly because you tread on my dreams." -W.B. Yeats
- Everyday, education treads on children and young people's dreams.
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Innovation and Teaching



Friday, May 07, 2010
Mac vs PC ... and Ellen DeGeneres
Leading Learning: Our Principle Purpose
The groups thinking has been informed by the work of Vivianne Robinson on leadership that has an impact on student outcomes and Helen Timperley on professional learning that improves student learning (teacher inquiry and knowledge building).
This learning meeting followed on from a successful staff development day for all the schools in the Learning Community. The principals and assistant principals brought along their thinking as to the goals for the year and key strategies the intended to use.
The meeting aimed to support these leaders in clarifying their goals, think about what their theory of action is to bring about the desired change and identify their learning needs as leaders.
My own reflections and learnings from the meeting are that:
- Developing precision around vision and expressing this as a couple of goals that are clear and unambiguous is hard work;
- Monitoring the effectiveness requires deep thinking in the planning stage; and
- engaging in open to learning conversations requires new skills and a shift away from monitoring, compliance and accountability mindsets.
Saturday, May 01, 2010
Looking for opportunities: Systemic reform, system learning? (Part 2)

This isn’t the Part 2 I had intended – but I thought that it is an example of how the system may actually be getting in the way of improvement and transformation.
Yesterday I picked up a series of Tweets from Greg Whitby about a recent policy talk from NSW opposition leader, Barry O’Farrell on proposed education policy. It had all the usual suspects:
- Real choice for parents
- Flexible system
- Evidence-based policy reporting
And light on detail.
The identified policy problem was that there is
“one in five Year 9 students at or below the minimum [Australian National] standards in reading, writing and maths; it’s time to change our approach towards literacy and numeracy.”
More of the same. So what have we learnt?
The proposed O’Farrell plan for NSW focuses on investing in early intervention in literacy and numeracy and commitment to ensuring
“children develop the foundations for success in literacy and numeracy at an early age.”
No one can really disagree with this. It’s common-sense. And it's been a focus for improvement for nearly two decades now. (see Hill and Crévola (1997); Fullan, Hill and Crévola (2006); Fullan and Sharratt (2010)).
The proposed policy solutions appear to be about doing more of the same: providing more intervention teachers, more accountability, more measuring, national and international comparisons.
An old model, no structural change.
There is also an assumption that a focus on the early years and establishing strong foundations will solve the literacy and numeracy issues in later years.
How does this thinking contribute to the student learning outcomes we have? Where is the learning for the system? How have policy-makers, politicians and political cycles contributed to the educational outcomes we have? What have we learnt?
Are we asking the right questions?
At the school level we have come to understand what makes a difference to student learning:
- Teachers do make a difference. Some things make a bigger difference - use of data, feedback, explicit teaching (Hattie (2009), Visible Learning; Steve Dinham (2009), How to get your school moving and improving).
- Particular approaches to professional learning that are focused on student learning outcomes, teacher inquiry and knowledge building (Timperley (2009), Teacher Professional Learning and Development).
- Particular actions of leadership focused on student learning (Robinson (2009), School Leadership and Student Outcomes: Identifying what works and why).
I have started to frame questions around these understandings.
- What is it about my teaching that leads to those student outcomes?
- What is it I do as a leader that leads to those student outcomes?
- What can I change in my teaching and leadership to achieve better outcomes and opportunities for students?
I use these questions when working with schools to open up reflection, thinking, analysis of practice and conversations about learning.
The same questions I think can be asked at higher levels:
- What is it I do in my work with schools that contributes to those student outcomes?
- What is it I have done as a policy maker that contributes to those student outcomes?
New thinking for new solutions
Doing more of the same, but more intensely, won’t address the issues of improving learning for all students; nor will it create the solutions we need.
Part of the problem is partisan politics within short-term political cycles. There has been very little inquiry into how policy-makers and politicians contribute to "one in five Year 9 students at or below the minimum [Australian National] standards in reading, writing and maths."
The complexity of the issues that face schools in the first decades of the 21st Century requires long-term solutions focused on deeper change. There needs to be a stronger focus on learning across the system - learning for students, teachers, school leaders, educational bureaucracy leaders and administrators, parents, policy-makers, politicians, and researchers.
The answer has to be deep engagement with other colleagues and with mentors in exploring, refining, and improving their practice as well as setting up an environment in which this not only can happen but is encouraged, rewarded, and pressed to happen.’ (Fullan, M. 2006: 57, Turnaround Leadership.)
Shouldn’t policy create those conditions that are necessary for the educational professionals to engage in inquiry, innovation, development and research that is focused on improving outcomes and opportunities for all students?
Image: http://science.nationalgeographic.com/science/photos/brain/#brain-neurons_849_600x450.jpg

